Thursday Boot is almost the standard now for entry-level boots, but it's worth noting that they carry oxfords and derbies. No experience with them, personally.
Thursday boots are fantastic at their price point. $200 for firsts and $150 for seconds.
The boots look good and are very comfortable. I have a pair going on 3 years and I wear them often.
On a side note, I do wonder what the point of GYW shoes are at this price point. I don't think it makes any sense to re-sole an entry level shoe. Blake stitched basically look the same and can often be lighter and more comfortable.